If there's one thing that "Suits" accomplishes, it's capturing attention. Since its debut, the legal drama has enchanted viewers with its high-stakes courtroom battles and charismatic characters. But how close does it come to actual legal practice? The show can often feel like a rollercoaster of accuracy and fiction for legal professionals, especially defense attorneys.
The Appeal of "Suits"
"Suits" is undeniably binge-worthy, with a captivating storyline centered around Harvey Specter and his protégé Mike Ross, who works at a prestigious New York City law firm despite not being a licensed attorney. The series portrays an adrenaline-fueled legal world, but how accurate is it? Let us dissect some of the most glaring discrepancies from the perspective of a defense lawyer.
Inaccuracies in "Suits" That Stand Out
The Innocent vs. Not Guilty Verdict
One of the recurring themes in "Suits" is the pursuit of proving innocence. However, in real-life criminal law, the verdicts are "guilty" or "not guilty"—there is no official "innocent" verdict. The prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt; if they fail, the jury can find the defendant not guilty. This does not necessarily mean the defendant is innocent; it is just that the evidence did not meet the legal standard for conviction.
Ex Parte Communication
"Suits" often depicts lawyers having private conversations with judges—a practice known as ex parte communication. In reality, this is illegal and grounds for a mistrial. Both parties must be present to discuss a case with the judge to ensure fairness and transparency.
Unrealistic Trial Timelines
The series frequently shows cases going to trial within a week of being charged. In practice, preparing for a criminal trial takes months or even years. The process involves extensive discovery, investigation, and preparation. As depicted in the show, prosecutors and a defense lawyer can't simply move trial dates on a whim.
Misleading Deposition Practices
"Suits" shows depositions as a routine part of criminal cases, often with video cameras rolling in law firm conference rooms. In reality, depositions do not occur in criminal cases as in civil cases. Criminal defendants have the right to remain silent, and depositions are typically reserved for gathering information in civil litigation.
Unauthorized Legal Representation
The entire premise of "Suits" hinges on Mike Ross practicing law without a license. While the show tries to provide some justification, the reality is that knowingly allowing an unlicensed individual to practice law is fraud. This would have severe legal consequences for all parties involved.
The Enticing Fiction of "Suits"
Despite its inaccuracies, "Suits" remains a beloved series that keeps audiences hooked. Its portrayal of legal practice may be far from real-world defense law. Still, it presents an engaging narrative that captures the imagination of viewers who might not be familiar with the intricacies of the legal system or how a defense lawyer must work within the rules.
The Takeaway
For law firms and legal professionals, "Suits" can serve as a reminder of the importance of ethical practices and the complexities of the legal field. While the show offers a dramatized version of the law, it is crucial to remember that real-life legal practice involves precise processes, ethical standards, and a commitment to truth and justice.
If you are involved in the legal industry, it is always important to separate fact from fiction and uphold the profession's integrity. And if you're a fan of "Suits" looking for more insights into the legal world, consider contacting a real-life defense lawyer to learn more about the nuances of defense law.
Contact Criminal Defense Lawyer Diane C. Bass
Attorney Diane C. Bass has represented some of Southern California’s most high-profile, high-stakes criminal defense cases. She prides herself on creating a healthy attorney-client relationship that clients can trust when dealing with criminal law issues.
If you or a loved one are in trouble and need help, please contact Diane C. Bass for your consultation.